Just as “Revise and Resubmit” is not a rejection, revising and resubmitting your manuscript isn’t a guarantee of acceptance. Some consider a Revise/Resubmit decision as a tacit acceptance, but really there are no promises here, particularly if you are called upon to make major revisions to your manuscript.
Is getting a revise and resubmit good?
Authors receiving a “revise and resubmit” decision are not likely to do a happy dance upon receiving the email. “Revise and resubmit” (or it’s sibling decision of “reject and resubmit”) often means that there is something the editor (or possibly reviewers) liked, but the paper needs a good bit of work.
Do papers get rejected after revise and resubmit?
A revise and resubmit is not a conditional acceptance. There is no guarantee that if you do what the referees ask for, your paper will be accepted. Especially at top journals, there may be multiple rounds of resubmission, and this is still no guarantee of publication.
What does a revise and resubmit mean?
When submitting your writing for publication in a journal, the best you can often hope for is to receive a “revise and resubmit” request from the editor. This means the reviewers and editor found value in your manuscript, but want to see revisions.
What is the difference between major revisions and revise and resubmit?
Major revision indicates the manuscript definitely needs some work and will require additional review, but the manuscript is in decent shape, the research is sound, etc. Revise and resubmit is just a step below reject.
Do papers get rejected after revise and resubmit?
A revise and resubmit is not a conditional acceptance. There is no guarantee that if you do what the referees ask for, your paper will be accepted. Especially at top journals, there may be multiple rounds of resubmission, and this is still no guarantee of publication.
Can a paper be rejected after major revision?
Answer: Unfortunately, sometimes manuscript do get rejected after the second or even third round of revisions. This can happen due to multiple reasons such as: The authors might not have adequately addressed all the questions raised by the reviewers.
How long should a revise and resubmit take?
Times vary. In my field three weeks for minor and six weeks for major revisions seems common. If the journal does not provide any general guidelines on this one would hope that the editor would do so.
What happens after revise and resubmit?
Once you’ve finished revising, the next step is writing the letter or memo that you will send with the revised version of your article. The “revise and resubmit letter” documents how you have responded to all of your reviewers’ comments.
How do you respond to R&R?
Step One: Read the Letter. Other possible responses from the editor include: 1) Reject without an invitation to re-submit; 2) Conditional acceptance, where you are asked to make minor changes; and 3) Outright acceptance, where changes are not required, but might be suggested.
How do I list revise and resubmit on my resume?
Generally, when I have a paper that is just submitted, I put it on my CV and indicate “under review” and do NOT name the journal. If it has received a revise and resubmit, I put it on my CV as “invited revision” and do put the name of the journal there too. If its in revision, put the journal name.
Can you resubmit a rejected paper?
Yes. In fact, some journals encourage resubmission after some months. But such resubmission would have addressed concerns from the previous review. In some other cases, Editor can request that a resubmission should have about 50% changes.
Do minor revisions go back to reviewers?
Minor revisions explained An editorial decision of ‘minor revisions’ on your paper means that your work will almost certainly not be going back to the original peer reviewers for a further round of comments; indeed this is policy for many journals.
What does resubmit for review mean?
This is common when minor revisions are required which the editor can approve without re-submitting for review. Resubmit for Review: The editor can request revisions from the author which will need to go through another round of review.
What is the difference between minor and major revisions?
In my field (chemistry), the practice is: for those journals that make a clear distinction between minor and major revision requests, “major revision” means that the paper will have to undergo further review after revision, usually by the same referees, while “minor revision” means that while changes should be made, no …
What happens after revise and resubmit?
Once you’ve finished revising, the next step is writing the letter or memo that you will send with the revised version of your article. The “revise and resubmit letter” documents how you have responded to all of your reviewers’ comments.
How do I list revise and resubmit on my resume?
Generally, when I have a paper that is just submitted, I put it on my CV and indicate “under review” and do NOT name the journal. If it has received a revise and resubmit, I put it on my CV as “invited revision” and do put the name of the journal there too. If its in revision, put the journal name.
What does a major revision mean?
In short, “major revisions” means you’ve got work to do on your manuscript, but you’re still very much in the game. You had a great research idea to start with. You’re not far from getting it accepted and published. Your target journal’s editor has sent your manuscript to two or more peer reviewers.
How do you write a cover letter for resubmission?
In the cover letter for the resubmission, thank the editors and reviewers for their feedback and outline the changes you made (or did not make) to the manuscript to address the feedback. The cover letter for a revised and resubmitted manuscript summarizes the changes to the manuscript.
Do papers get rejected after revise and resubmit?
A revise and resubmit is not a conditional acceptance. There is no guarantee that if you do what the referees ask for, your paper will be accepted. Especially at top journals, there may be multiple rounds of resubmission, and this is still no guarantee of publication.
What is the difference between major revisions and revise and resubmit?
Major revision indicates the manuscript definitely needs some work and will require additional review, but the manuscript is in decent shape, the research is sound, etc. Revise and resubmit is just a step below reject.
What is probability of acceptance after major revision?
Of course, not all papers will make it through the revision stage, but the same publisher also reports that major revision requests only reduce the chance of acceptance by about 16% compared with minor revisions.
